Posts tagged as:

Western Australia

We have recently passed the two year anniversary of the death of Mr Ward who died while being transported in a prisoner transport vehicle in summer without air-conditioning. A former prisoner has provided a first hand account of what these vehicles are like to travel in.

The following account is from Kalgoorlie. Miner newspaper. Visit their site and see what happens in Kal.

Kalgoorlie Miner

NATASHA BODDY 28th January 2010

The two-year anniversary of the death in custody of a Goldfields Aboriginal elder has prompted a former prisoner to speak out about the “degrading” conditions in which prisoners were transported.

The former prisoner, who did not want his name published, said the conditions in which some prisoners were transported were “degrading”, “filthy” and “inhumane”.

The man told the Kalgoorlie Miner he was transported in a prison van in similar conditions to those in which 46-year-old father of four Mr Ward died.

Mr Ward was arrested in Laverton on Australia Day 2008 for drink-driving while serving a suspended jail term for other driving offences. He was remanded in custody to face court in Kalgoorlie 360km away and suffered third-degree burns to his stomach following his collapse in the rear of a prison van in which the air conditioning was not working.

prisoner transport van Western Australia

Given only a 600ml bottle of water and a meat pie for the journey, Mr Ward later died from heat stroke on the 42C day.

Speaking out after Mr Ward’s death, the former prisoner said he could understand how Mr Ward died because he was transported in similar conditions.

“When Mr Ward died I could see exactly how it happened,” he said. “The way they transported prisoners was wrong and it was just inhumane.”

The man said when he was remanded in custody to travel from Kalgoorlie-Boulder to a Perth prison, he was transported in the back of a prison van similar to one in which Mr Ward collapsed.

“We were transported from Kalgoorlie to Perth and we were herded into the back like sheep,” he said.

“If it tipped over, you’re a goner.”

He said conditions inside the prison van were “filthy” and “degrading” with prisoners often crammed into metal pods at the back of the vehicle.

“There were 12 of us in the back of the prison van and the smell from the toilet was unbelievable,” he said. “It was a hot day and I dry-retched when I climbed in because of the smell. It hadn’t been cleaned.”

The former inmate said while there was a toilet inside the van, unlike the vehicle in which Mr Ward was transported, it was filthy and many prisoners did not want to use it.

“We were given 600ml of water like Mr Ward and we had wet sandwiches, but the guys didn’t want to drink the water because if they needed the toilet, they would have to expose themselves in front of all the other prisoners,” he said.

Like Mr Ward, the former prisoner said he was never told about a duress alarm installed in the back of the vehicle, nor was he told how to communicate with the guards driving the prison van.

“You don’t get spoken to, there’s no communication,” he said.

He told the Kalgoorlie Miner although the guards had stopped twice during the journey to Perth in August last year, they did not stop to check on prisoners inside.

“THEY stopped two times but didn’t open the back to see how we were,” he said.

He said though the air conditioning was functioning in the prison van in which he was transported, the former prisoner said it was “freezing”.

During the inquest into Mr Ward’s death, State Coroner Alastair Hope heard evidence from Nina Stokoe, one of the guards who transported Mr Ward, who said she assumed the air conditioning in the pod had been working because the driver’s cabin had functioning air conditioning.

Mr Hope also heard evidence staff from the private prisoner transport company, GSL, now G4S, had repeatedly complained about the sub-standard vehicles used to transport prisoners and the air conditioning had been reported faulty at least one month before Mr Ward’s death.

Mr Ward’s inquest also revealed chronic deficiencies in the Government-owned fleet of prison vans were well-known to the Department of Corrective Services and a report had been tabled in Parliament in 2001 following a highly-critical review by a former inspector of custodial services.

Some months later, the Department of Corrective Services announced prisoners would be transported in chartered buses and planes until the fleet of long-haul vehicles was replaced.

Though some changes have been implemented to privatised custodial services and prisoner transport in WA, the former prisoner said he simply hoped prisoners transport would improve in the wake of Mr Ward’s tragic death.

“There has got to be a better way,” he said.

Your email:

 

{ 5 comments }

A recent ‘Short Communication‘ to the Rural and Remote Health Journal looked at the results of a very small survey to determine what telehealth needs were most required out bush.

The survey looked at the views of health managers and physicians working in non-metropolitan areas of Western Australia as to what the telehealth priorities were.

While the order of the first four health priorities was different, both groups had the same collective priorities.

Health managers wanted telehealth services (in priority order) for wound care, emergency, psychiatry and ophthalmology. Doctors wanted telehealth mainly for psychiatry (35%), wound care, emergency and ophthalmology.

To have a better sample size I see no reason why remote health services could not have been included. Telehealth is even more important in these areas where in some areas patients can be away for at least a week just to attend a specialist appointment.

In my belief the needs would have been the same, particularly mental health as mental illness is the second largest cause of illness in remote areas of Australia

If you like this post and what else you see on the blog please subscribe by RSS feed (the orange button) or by email. Visit my subscription page.

{ 2 comments }

The following has come from a recent editorial in eurekastreet.com.au . I recommend reading the complete editorial.

The Edmund Rice Institute for Social Justice, Fremantle, has called for a large ex-gratia payment to the family of Mr Ward. The 46-year-old Aboriginal elder and cultural leader died on 27 January 2008 while being transported from Laverton to Kalgoorlie, in the back of a privatised prison van. His first name cannot be revealed for cultural reasons.

The report of Coroner Alistair Hope was published on 12 June this year. It concluded that Ward died of heatstroke, and that the WA Department of Corrective Services, the prison transport company GSL (now G4S) and the two drivers were jointly to blame. The coroner said Ward’s treatment was inhumane, and a breach of international laws to which Australia is a signatory.

In a statement issued after the Coroner’s report, Edmund Rice Institute director David Freeman said the report confirmed fears that this is ‘one of the worst human rights tragedies in Australian living memory’.

The Indigenous News Updates are sourced from news and other articles from around the country that I have posted on Twitter.

If you like this post and what else you see on the blog please subscribe by RSS feed (the orange button) or by email. Visit my subscription page.

{ 2 comments }

The last desert wanderers were seen by members of the Kiwirrkurra community. Well, not seen as you and I would see them, but their tracks were seen and destination determined. Members of the community waited for them near a water supply and gave them clothes to wear before bringing them into the community so they would not be shamed by white fella remarks as the community members remembered receiving in years past when they stopped their nomadic way of life.

This was 1984.

Sixteen years later in late 2000 and early 2001 massive rains flooded out the community of Kiwirrkurra. 170 people had to be evacuated initially to Alice Springs, and after a month back into Western Australia, 2000kms SSW of Kiwirrkurra to Moropoi Station. Kiwirrkurra was (and is) alcohol free but during their time at Alice Springs and at Moropoi alcohol was freely available. This dislocation of a desert people caused severe disruption to their community social fabric. It would be eighteen months before they could go home to their country. the land that sustains them.

The current edition of The Australian Journal of Emergency Management produced by the Federal Attorney-General’s Department contains an article an article about the flooding of 2000 and what can be improved in the planning.

A project recently completely by Emergency Management Australia, in consultation with the Fire and Emergency Services Authority of WA, (FESA) has documented the communities stories from the Kiwirrkurra flood to identify the lessons learned, so that other communities and emergency managers can benefit.

The article can be downloaded here (192Kb). It is a good read looking at the difficulties with remote life. My only concern with the article is their is no mention of the role of the health service in any emergency.

Disclaimer: Kiwirrkurra is one of the communities I look after

If you like this post and what else you see on the blog please subscribe by RSS feed (the orange button) or by email. Visit my subscription page.

Blog Widget by LinkWithin

{ 4 comments }